Nikki LaDue January’s Mother–On A Mission For Truth

There’s so much about the case of Nikki LaDue January’s death that just doesn’t add up. After the county coroner declared her death a suicide, the family went so far as to have her body exhumed and for the first time, an autopsy was done by a private medical examiner. His findings showed her death was not suicide but rather, undetermined. Yes she died of a gunshot wound. There’s no argument there. But whether it was Nikki who pulled the trigger or someone else, this autopsy could not say. Bonnie LaDue, Nikki’s mom hired a private investigator. After conducting several interviews and telling her he would prove who did this to Nikki, he suddenly up and quit the investigation. Was he scared off?

Then there’s the local paper the Sun Herald. Once again, a brick wall for Bonnie.

“Starting in the fall of 2002 the crime reporter, Robin Fitzgerald, was contacted multiple times regarding Nikki’s suspicious death,” Bonnie said. ” The first contact was via a phone call.  She indicated strong interest and asked for about a week to do some research before getting back to us. Months went by and all calls and emails to her were ignored. After pleading with her to at least acknowledge our communications, she finally responded in an email that she had spoken with the coroner (Gary T. Hargrove) whom she highly respected.  He had assured her that Nikki had taken her own life.  She ended the letter with condolences on losing a loved one to suicide. We quickly wrote back questioning her biased stance and asked how a crime writer could so easily draw conclusions based on the account of only one (suspicious) person without benefit of hearing what we had to say, and especially since no investigation had been conducted.  She responded immediately with a request that we send all our contact info (which we did)…total silence.

“In 2007, she was contacted by phone again.  Several of Nikki’s advocates were going to be in the Biloxi area and would she be willing to meet with them?  She said yes.  They went to the Sun Herald offices on the appointed day only to be told by the receptionist that Ms. Fitzgerald was out, but that she would call the number left for her as soon as she returned.  Not only did this not happen, they later learned that Robin had instructed the receptionist to lie…she had been right there and watched/heard everything that happened at the front desk.  There has been no further contact with her.”

All Bonnie wants is the truth. All anyone wants is the truth. It’s been more than 9 years. It’s time for Mississippi, Harrison County, and the Pass Christian Police to take another look at what happened to one of their citizens.  Despite all the references to drugs, she was addicted to pain pills following a surgery. But she was fighting that addiction, and winning. To paint her as your classic drug addict, stoned all the time with needles handing out couldn’t be further from the truth. Nikki was a great mother. She was a caring person who loved her family. Her life was her son Zack. She did not kill herself. It’s about time someone from the law enforcement community realizes this, takes note of all the inconsistencies, and does a proper investigation. It’s easy to close a case and get it off your desk. It’s a travesty of justice if that case is closed without so much as a cursory investigation. It’s not too late for that. As more information becomes available, I will continue to follow Nikki’s story and keep you updated.

In closing, here is Nikki’s story as told by her mother.

Nichole LaDue January

My daughter, Nichole LaDue January, 30, was found dead of a gunshot wound to the head on the balcony of her third floor condo in Pass Christian,Mississippi, shortly before 10 a.m.onJuly 29, 2002.  Rigor and lividity indicated that she had been dead for hours.

Within two hours police closed the case as a suicide.  The chief investigator, Pass Christian Police Officer Tom Putsay, told our family that  no autopsy or investigation was deemed necessary.  No fingerprints were taken and there was no gun powder residue test to determine whether Nikki had fired a gun.  Strong physical evidence that somebody was on the balcony with Nikki at the time of the shooting was totally ignored, as was information from several individuals that Nikki’s death was very likely linked to an interstate drug operation involving people from the Grand Casino in Gulfport.

Nikki had been married for less than two years to Phil January, and both worked at the Grand Casino, as did Nikki’s former husband, Mike Williams.  According to Nikki’s friends, Phil was a jealous and controlling husband.  Her co-workers told us that our formerly fun-loving daughter had become a loner, afraid to socialize on breaks because Phil had spies watching her.  However, she did have something wonderful in her life – a  5-year-old son, Zachary, from her previous marriage.  She loved Zack with all her heart.

At the time of her death, Nikki was at a point of transition.  Phil had suddenly decided they should relocate to Bossier City,Louisiana, where he had found a job with Boomtown Casino’s security department under Frank Brown, his former boss at the Grand.  Nikki had stayed behind to orchestrate the move. The plan as presented was that, on July 29, Phil would drive to Mississippi, rent a U-Haul, then collect their household possessions and take them to Louisiana.  Nikki and Zack, along with Nikki’s friend, Nancy Burge, who also worked at Grand Casino, would then drive to Fort Lauderdale in Nikki’s car to spend a week with our family before Nikki dropped Nancy off at her home in Gulfport and joined Phil in Bossier City.

But Nikki had a plan of her own, which she had confided to only a few people.  She had told one of those friends, Keith Oliver, that her marriage to Phil was over and she had no intention of joining him in Louisiana. She and Zack were going to remain with us in Florida and start a new life there.  That decision became quite evident after her death, when we discovered that she and Nancy were going to make the 12 hour road trip in separate vehicles and that Nancy’s SUV was loaded with Nikki’s and Zack’s possessions.

According to friends, Nikki seemed both exhilarated and nervous.  She was excited about coming to us, but she also seemed scared.  She and Zack slept atNancy’s house, because Nikki was afraid to spend nights alone in the condo.  She also asked a male friend to show her how to use a pistol, because she wanted to be able to protect herself.  (She died before he had a chance to do so.)  That was an unusual request, since Nikki was terrified of guns.

The day before Phil was due to arrive with the U-Haul, Nikki apparently decided to treat herself to a preview of her new life as a single woman.  She deposited Zack with a sitter and went on a date!  She and her new friend, Eric, went to a club and then to his apartment, where he introduced her to some of his friends.  From there they went to a sports bar.

Meanwhile, Phil’s calls were piling up on Nikki’s voice mail.  He even placed a frantic call to Nancy at work to find out where Nikki was. Nancy, as Nikki’s best friend, undoubtedly knew about Eric and may or may not have told Phil.

At about 8 p.m.Nikki looked at her watch and exclaimed that she HAD to make a call immediately.  She refused to use Eric’s cell and called from a pay phone.  When she returned to the table she was visibly shaken and stated she had to leave “RIGHT NOW!”  That was the last time Eric saw her alive, though they did speak one final time at 12:30 a.m., when she called his cell to swear him to secrecy about their day together.

Once Nikki collected Zack and returned to the condo, the barrage of phone calls continued, all incoming from a blocked phone. Phil has identified those 18 calls, made between 11 p.mand2 a.m., as a lover’s spat and told police he said some hurtful things that might have caused Nikki to search the condo for Phil’s gun and kill herself.  Months later, the detective in charge of the case told us that this statement by Phil was the basis for his conclusion of suicide. Phil also told police that he was a 20-year veteran of the police force in Wichita Falls,TX.  That was a total lie. Phil was never employed by any police department in Texas.

Nikki’s friend, Nancy, allegedly arrived at Nikki’s apartment at about 9:30 help load the U-Haul.  She was let in by Zack, who said Mommy was sleeping in the bedroom.  Nancy allegedly searched the condo twice for Nikki, but never looked out on the balcony. Minutes later Phil arrived and discovered Nikki’s body. Phil has never provided us with proof of his whereabouts that night or explained why he blocked the phone records from showing where he was calling from.  He might have been en route to Mississippi, but it’s possible that he was already there and Nikki didn’t know it.  In Nancy’s call to 911, she stated that Phil “came in tonight … the (girl) was supposed to move today.”

Nothing about the scene of the shooting makes sense.  Nikki was found in a chair with her right knee held by the table in front of her and her left leg down. Phil, the person who found her, has stated in writing, “The gun was sitting beside her on a small padded wicker stool with rod-iron railing.” However, the police photo shows Phil’s pistol on the chair, under Nikki’s left thigh.  (How do you shoot yourself in the temple, and then place the pistol under your thigh?)   On the table lay a pack of Nikki’s Marlboro Medium 100s, but they were to her left, not to the right where a right-handed person would normally place them.  On the far side of the table lay a pack of Marlboro Red 100’s with a lighter beside them. To me, that says that somebody else was there that night.  There was also a portable phone, face down on the table, covered with blood. A pathologist that we hired to do a private autopsy told us that Nikki died instantly.  So who bloodied the telephone?  Since police didn’t seize it as evidence, we’ll never know whose prints were on it or on the lighter.

The bullet that entered Nikki’s right temple exited through a tiny hole above her left ear.  Allegedly it then hit the wall 5 feet 6 inches from the floor and 18 inches to Nikki’s left, ricocheted into the aluminum door frame on the same wall, and then bounced back to land in a chair on the next balcony. Police took no scene photos to document those facts.  It seems strange that the exit wound was so small that three different funeral directors were unable to locate it, yet the bullet continued to travel at such a speed as to hit a wall, travel to the door frame, and have enough momentum left to fly back over Nikki’s head and land on a balcony six feet away.  There is no police diagram of the path of the bullet, just a verbal description.

A maintenance man found a shell casing in a swimming pool, 20 feet over from the balcony and three floors down.  The gun, which was owned by Phil, was aSterling.380 semi automatic.  The caliber of the bullet and casing was not identified in police reports, but the man who found the casing told me he thought it was a 9 mm., which cannot be fired from a .380. The coroner told me the bullet was a metal jacket, but Phil was specific that his gun was loaded with plain lead bullets.

Aside from the crazy hodgepodge of physical evidence, I have personal reasons to believe that Nikki didn’t kill herself:

  •  Nikki’s son was found alone in the condo hours after her death.  (He was never questioned by anyone).  Had Nikki intended to commit suicide, she easily could have left Zack at the babysitter’s where he’d already spent the afternoon.  It’s inconceivable that this devoted mother would put a gun to her head with her child there.
  •  Nikki had a great fear of guns and was not known to ever have fired one. Conversely, she struggled with an addiction to prescription painkillers, and had easy access to them.  So why would she choose such a violent way to kill herself?

It has been suggested to me many times that I just can’t accept that my daughter was capable of suicide.  Not true.  What I can’t accept are the myriad unanswered questions and the unwillingness and/or inability of the Pass Christian Police to show me how suicide fits to form a complete picture. It appears that either Nikki’s death meant nothing to them or that some bigger factor was in play.

Phil; Nikki; Nikki’s former husband Mike Williams; Nancy Burge and most of Nikki’s other friends all worked at a casino.  A lot of illegal activity goes on in such places.  If Phil did not kill Nikki in a rage of jealousy – (I would love to believe that he’s innocent) – the obvious next possibility is that her murder was a warning to Phil, who had already been fired from two security jobs, to keep his mouth shut, now that he’d left the state and was no longer under the control of casino bosses.  It’s also possible a similar message was meant for Nancy, whose behavior and demeanor since the killing have been very suspicious. Nancydidn’t even come to Nikki’s funeral.  When I told her my reasons for believing that Nikki was murdered, there was a long silence.  Then she said softly, “Then, perhaps I should be scared also.”

We’ve received information that, in March, 2003, the Grand Casino conducted an internal investigation of Grand personnel and their alleged involvement with the distribution of illegal drugs. In the course of that investigation, information surfaced about “The Oxy Ring,” a group of individuals at the Grand Casino who allegedly travel to New Orleans andHouston to obtain Oxycontin from crooked doctors.  Those drugs are then brought back and sold on the street.   We’ve also learned that, on Sunday, July 28, 2002, a big drug party was held at a private residence and attended by people from the Grand. Nikki is said to have attended. Allegedly no one remembers what time she left or if someone accompanied or followed her.  What we do know for sure is that she was shot soon after that.  A cocktail waitress at the Grand told one investigator, “Nikki’s death was definitely drug related.  And, trust me, we all got the message.”

The possibility that Nikki’s death may be linked to organized crime is something the Pass Christian Police will not touch with a stick.  Nor will anyone else in Mississippi.  I’ve written numerous letters to state and county agencies, begging for someone to look into this matter.  From the governor to the DA, I received the same response – “Take it to the local police.”  That’s not much help when the local police won’t look at it.

It is my firm belief that to date the truth has not been told, and I am prepared to search for it until I die.  Nikki was a beloved daughter, granddaughter, sister, mother, niece and friend.  She was the sweetheart of our world. No one who knew her is likely to forget the impact she made in each of our lives nor will we ever stop missing her smile.  We all deserve to know and understand why she is gone.  But, above all, Zack, who lost the most important person in his life, will one day need to be told the truth.

Bonnie LaDue (Nikki’s mom)


Posted on November 29, 2011, in Cold Cases, Crime, Murder, Nikki LaDue January and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.


    “The Table and Chairs”

    One of the photos taken of the crime scene shows the contents of a small table with 2 chairs situated at either side. In one chair sits Nikki’s lifeless body. The other chair is, of course, vacant. However, the angle of that second chair is very interesting to me and started me thinking a bit more. Both chairs are angled in such a way around the table that would suggest 2 people were sitting there the night Nikki died. Why? The table isn’t very big in diameter, and for both individuals to scoot up to it, they’d have to angle their chairs so that they didn’t knock knees or step on each other’s feet.

    Now let’s look at the contents of the table – in particular the ashtray (i.e. spent cigarette butts), the Marlboro Red cigarette pack, and the lighter closest to the vacant chair. The position of each of these is consistent with a person sitting in the vacant chair the night Nikki died. The position and angle of the lighter is consistent with an individual sitting in the vacant chair that uses his right hand to activate the lighter when lighting cigarettes. The position and angle of the Marlboro Red cigarette pack is consistent with an individual sitting in the vacant chair that holds a cigarette pack in his left hand when he withdraws a cigarette to light. Looking at the spent cigarette butts in the ashtray, the position and angle of the most recently smoked (i.e. top layer) cigarette butts are consistent with being extinguished by somebody sitting in the vacant chair and using his left hand to snuff out the cigarettes. Looking at the ashtray, there’s only 1 cigarette butt in the top layer that Nikki appears to have extinguished (though the full contents of the ashtray is obscured from view).

    Nikki was a smoker, but she didn’t smoke Marlboro reds. The position of Nikki’s cigarette pack and lighter don’t make sense to me, given where she was sitting. Why would a smoker place her cigarette pack and lighter on the opposite side of the table to which she was sitting (I believe the position of her cigarette pack was moved after Nikki died, without necessarily changing the orientation of the pack.

    As a smoker, when I’m nervous, anxious, or wound up, I smoke more. That’s just what smokers do. Judging from the contents of the ashtray, was the individual sitting in the vacant chair particularly anxious on this night?

    What are the implications here? Two scenarios come to mind. One possibility — it appears Nikki knew her killer. They may have sat at the table and had a discussion prior to her death. Possibly the individual was trying to persuade Nikki to do (or not do) something (i.e. don’t leave me). When the killer realized Nikki could no longer be controlled, did he get up and end her life? Or possibly, he jumped up after Nikki began feeling threatened and picked up the phone to call police? The other possibility is that the killer surprised Nikki on the balcony, killed her, and then sat down at the table to contemplate what to do next (an amateur without a meticulous well-crafted and thought out plan who had acted on impulse and emotion). Neither of the 2 possibilities described above would suggest Nikki’s murder was a mob hit left in the hands of a hired professional. However, they do point to a very obvious suspect. And the evidence strongly suggests Nikki was not alone the night of her death.

    One other observation . . . investigators suggested the black case shown on the table is a camera case (put there while taking crime scene photos). However, the photos they took at the crime scene were Polaroids. Circa 2002, I was still using a Polaroid camera from time to time at my own job. These cameras were rather large and bulky – and would not have fit into the case shown on the table. In short, it’s just another explanation provided by the crime scene investigators that, although convenient, does not appear plausible.

  1. Pingback: A Catch-Up Post For the Nikki LaDue January Case « Cold No More

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: